A short story I wrote recently. It needs a lot of work, but here is my most recent draft.
Crash
I raise my hand, signaling to the teacher’s aide that I’m finished with my lab. She walks over, checks my barely-pink titration, and signs my worksheet as completed. Sometimes, college feels so much like high school, especially these entry-level courses I’m required to take. Transferring from private to state school without checking what credits transferred wasn’t one of my better ideas. I gather my things, leaving the cleanup for my half-assed lab partner who’s napping on the table next to me, his plastic goggles leaving unforgiving rings around his stoned eyes. I am usually the first to finish – as a junior, Chem 120 comes especially easily for me – but Mike, a friend I have known since middle school, has finished just ahead of me. He’s already out the door of the old brick building and is strolling towards the quad in the muggy September air.
“Mike, wait up man.” My long legs catch him quickly. “What are you up to tonight?”
“Oh, you know, probably going to hit up Ella and Paige’s place later. They were talking about getting a keg to celebrate Paige’s brother coming home from the Middle East. Should be a good crowd, you in?”
My heart jumps a beat at the mention of Ella’s name, but I push past that and try to focus. “He’s in the army? I didn’t know that,” I say.
“Not army, man, he’s a journalist. He’s been over there for eight months or so covering that prison that was torturing dudes. I’m sure he’s got a lot of great stories.”
I jump through my mental calendar and land on the test I have in thermodynamics Monday, but decide one night of seeing Ella, er, Paige’s brother couldn’t hurt. “I can meet you guys there after 10 or so. They still living over at Riverside?”
We chat for a few more steps about insignificant, student-oriented details and then part at a crosswalk, Mike heading south to his next class and me heading north towards the parking garage. Alone amongst the late-afternoon campus bustle, I kick a rock along the sidewalk and think about the evening ahead – what I should wear, logistics for a sober driver, whether or not I should bring my roommate, all on the forefront – while subconsciously Ella’s face is floating languidly on the surface of my mind. I haven’t seen her in several months, and even now I’m not completely sure that I want to. It still feels like there is debris beneath my skin from our last moments together. I’ve tried to heal, tried to just think about the good things, but actually seeing her… Physically, she can hold a man in a trance. God, is she beautiful. Her blue eyes, her black hair, the smooth curve of her waist flowing down towards her –
Smack. My thoughts are jarred by running face-first into a large black guy smoking a menthol outside the library. I apologize profusely while he glares at me, and I back away looking like the fool I am.
***
The exit ramp onto the highway between my apartment and Ella’s is stop-and-go because of an accident up ahead. I can see rotating blue and red lights nearby when traffic slows to a gridlock, and I fiddle with the radio, looking for something to distract me from my impatience. I look up and start with a yell at a man standing directly in my headlights and think absurdly that he looks like Jesus. He is holding a cardboard sign that reads, “HOMELESS VET. NEED $ FOR FOOD. GOD BLESS.” He apologetically smiles a black-toothed grin at my reaction and I realize my windows are down. He heads towards the driver’s side window and I am torn between rolling it up quickly and offending him or risking probable death by a secondhand samurai knife. My Grandmother Dorothy’s voice echoes in my head, telling me not to trust “those smelly beggar-folk,” but my father’s liberal voice resonates louder than hers and tells me to give the poor guy a chance.
“Hello there, sir.” His voice is gravelly but warm, and he looks right at me. His clothes are worn and dirty and his pack is patched up at the corners. His long white beard is laced with yellow tobacco stains, but despite my conservative grandmother’s warnings he doesn’t smell too bad. His blue eyes appear perfectly sober. “Got any spare change for an old man?”
I reach into my wallet and pull out a few singles and, upon second thought, hand over the bag of pretzels I was bringing for the party. I picture Grandmother Dorothy rolling around in her grave and mentally shrug. He takes them both with a grateful nod and presses a worn card into my hand before disappearing into the darkness alongside the highway.
I flip the card in my hand rightways. Looking for a second chance? Then, on the back: Jesus saves! An address is printed at the bottom for a non-denominational church a few counties over. My brow furrows and I am unsure whether to be offended or appreciative, but I toss the card into the passenger seat and shift my car into drive as traffic is now creeping slowly towards the highway.
***
I walk in the door of Ella’s apartment, freshly shaved, smelling like (too much?) cologne, carrying a 6-pack of Boulevard Wheat, and hope I don’t look like I’m trying too hard. The room is already full of people drinking, but even through the smoky cloud above the room I can easily pick out Ella’s long black hair. She’s sitting on the countertop in the kitchen next to Brent, Paige’s brother. She sees me enter and waves, smoothing out her top nervously. I tilt my chin in greeting (is that still cool? Should I wave?) and make my way through the crowd, depositing my beer in the fridge after removing one and cracking it open.
Brent is taller than I remember him, his skin tan and slightly weathered-looking. Despite this, he looks confident and strong, and I am hyperaware of Ella’s proximity to him as her legs dangle over the edge of the counter she’s sitting on. He’s in the middle of a story that has the girls enthralled. Ella is covering her mouth with her long, slender fingers and the “o” shape of her eyes mirrors Paige’s.
“Some of these prisoners – you couldn’t believe what they went through. Have you seen any of the pictures?” The girls shake their heads. “It was shocking…almost otherworldly. I didn’t know men were capable of doing some of that to other men.”
“What did they do?” Ella asks in a hushed voice.
“Torture, daily humiliation, rape, homicide, you name it. Part of my job was to micro-analyze the photographs for details that had been missed. I’ll never get some of that out of my head.”
By now, Mike has worked his way through the room and is leaning on the counter next to me. “That’s so messed up, man. What did they do to the soldiers? It’s been on the news, but I haven’t followed it too closely,” he says.
“Most were demoted or removed from service, a handful court-martialed and put in jail. Not enough of a punishment, if you ask me.” I can hear his journalism voice kicking in. “Dostoyevsky had it right – you can measure society by walking into its prisons.” A cute blonde walks through the kitchen to the fridge for another beer, throwing a flirtatious smile in Brent’s direction, but realizing how serious the conversation has turned she rolls her eyes and walks out. I watch her leave, unable to help staring just a little bit, and catch Ella looking at me looking at her. We both quickly revert our eyes back to Brent.
Mike raises his arms and points his palms at Brent. “Whoa, man, that’s not really fair. It wasn’t our society that was in those prisons to begin with, we were just guarding them.”
Brent turns toward him, and I myself am a bit intimidated. Mike visibly shrinks. “That quote is more about the prison guards than the prisoners. If we’re going to push democracy on the world, we should treat men with respect. Some of those soldiers got off far too easily. I mean, I don’t care who you are, not everybody deserves a second chance.”
Ella’s eyes snap up from the floor. Her feet stop swinging. “Sure they do. Everyone deserves forgiveness. Why would you say that?” she says.
“Forgiveness? Who was talking about forgiveness? Second chances and forgiveness are apples and oranges. You can forgive someone and not give them a second chance,” Brent says. He reaches out and pinches Ella on the forearm.
“Ah! What the hell was that for?”
“I’m sorry, I don’t know what got into me,” he says.
“It’s okay,” she says reluctantly, rubbing her arm. He smiles, then reaches out towards her once more, and she slaps his hand away. “Brent, what the hell –"
“What, you forgave me, didn’t you? Then why won’t you let me near your arm again?”
She falls silent, glaring at him. I stifle a smile, but I’m sure her quick eyes catch it. She slides down from the counter and storms up the stairs.
I’m pleased that his smug face looks somewhat confused. “What, was it something I said? I was just trying to prove a point.”
Mike looks from me to the stairs pointedly, then turns to Brent. “Don’t worry about it, bro, she’s always a little dramatic like that. Here, try this pumpkin beer I brought, it’s the first of the season.” He cracks the top on the bottle and hands him one while I steal away up the stairs.
I find Ella in her room sitting at her desk chair. I take a seat on the edge of the bed opposite her, feeling the reverberations of the party left behind through the floor. “What was that all about?” I ask stupidly. Hell, I know exactly what it was about… but I’m giving her a chance to back out.
“Don’t play that game, Jake. You know what it was about.” I love that she knows that about me. I hate that she knows that about me. She looks right into my eyes and says the one thing I’ve been hoping she wouldn’t say, she would say. “Do you believe in second chances?”
I swallow. “I don’t know, Ella. What happened –”
“Was in June! Four fucking months, and you just ignore me? You just cut me out of your life like I’m nothing, after everything we’ve been through?”
“I walked in on you with that creep and you expect me to forgive you just like that?”
“Not just like that. I’ve tried everything, and don’t you think four months of silence is enough torture?” She lowers her voice and comes to sit next to me on the bed. “Don’t you miss me? Don’t you miss this?” She takes my face in her hands and kisses me, her soft lips tasting sweet like the cosmopolitan she’d been sipping earlier. I fight off every instinct I have to keep some distance between us. Internally, I’m at war – my residual feelings for her battling my pride – but inevitably, my pride wins over. I push her away firmly. “Of course I miss it, Ella. But it’s not enough. Maybe he’s right – maybe everybody doesn’t deserve a second chance.”
I stand up. Without looking back, I walk out the door and down the stairs to join Mike and Brent for another beer.
***
Once outside, I fiddle with the keys, then reach out and touch my nose, getting a feel for my sense of depth perception. I hit the bridge – that’s close enough, right? – and besides, six beers in two and a half hours wouldn’t make a guy my size drunk. I stick the keys in the ignition and buckle my seatbelt in one, two tries. The engine roars to life and I back down the driveway, hearing an aluminum can crunch under my back tires, then my front ones. The highway is the quickest way back to my apartment, although there could be a few more cops that way (why am I worried about cops? Of course I’m okay to drive). Four exits and I’ll be in the clear (not that there’s anything unclear to get out of).
The highway is empty and dark, the grass grown a bit too tall on both sides, but no police cars are in sight so I step on the gas a little harder. I reach down to find a better radio station. My phone vibrates in my pocket and I pull it out. From Ella: Let me know when you get home okay. Sure, sure. I reach to put it back in my pocket when an earsplitting
THUD!
sounds from the front of the hood and my car goes into a wild spin – I hold on to the wheel as it jerks out of control – four seconds of my own screaming sounds like hours in my terrified mind and finally I am stopped in the middle of the highway, one headlight out and steam rising in small columns from the front end of my car. My mind is reeling and I can’t distinguish one beat of my heart from the next. My hands grip the wheel so hard that the knuckles are nearly see-through.
Minutes pass. I can already feel the tension and soreness settling in my neck and shoulder muscles. My breathing slows enough to consider seeing what the hell just happened. Shaky hands manage to unbuckle my seatbelt and I open the door and walk around to inspect the damage.
The front end of my car is significantly dented. I reach out to touch the grille and my hand comes back sticky and red. I turn around and look for the deer that is inevitably dying on the side of the road and see a mass twenty or so feet ahead, just out of reach of my one good headlight. Ugh. I can eat a steak like the best of carnivores, but I’m not prepared to see uncooked venison in the middle of the highway. I take a few steps forward just to make sure it’s dead and am surprised by a soft crunch underneath my feet. I look down.
There is a mass of brown crumbs and – what the? – are those pretzels?
I look forward to the mangled mess and the realization hits me like a second car accident. I feel strangely torn in two as my heart drops through my ribcage to my feet and I simultaneously rise out of my body and hover, no longer in control of myself. I run forward, knowing I shouldn’t look, but unable to stop myself – and see the homeless man from the exit ramp. He is lying face-up, his features nearly unrecognizable, the flesh stripped cruelly down to sinew and bone, blood trickling out of what is left of his ear, his neck at an irreconcilable angle to his body, his limbs appearing to have come undone at the hinges. His tobacco-stained beard is streaked with blood and flesh and – worst of all – his blue eyes are open, looking without seeing at the star-spotted twilight above.
I turn into the grass and retch violently until there is nothing left in me, the world spinning once more. My ears are ringing loudly and tears obscure my vision so that I don’t hear the police car approach or see the flashing lights until a deep voice booms, “Stand up and put your hands behind your head.”
I obey slowly, sobs escaping me at irregular intervals. “I didn’t mean to – I didn’t see him – oh my God, what have I –“ I am unable to finish. The officer lowers his voice but keeps his flashlight raised. He walks over to the homeless man and checks his pulse. He says something into his walkie that I can’t hear. He puts it away, walks back over and looks at me. “Have you been drinking this evening?” He shines the flashlight into my eyes.
I know there’s no point in lying. “Yes, sir, I just came from a party. I’m not drunk, but I have been drinking.”
“I need to see your license and registration.” I move slowly towards the car, trying my hardest to walk in a straight line, but the crash has seriously shaken me. I find what he’s asked for and remain sitting in the driver’s seat.
He looks at the license, then back at me. “Sarkozy. That’s not a very common name.”
“No, sir,” I respond. “Not in the Midwest it’s not.”
He runs his fingers along his chin stubble in thought. “You aren’t related to a Sid Sarkozy, are you?”
I blink in surprise. “Yes, sir, but I’ve never met him. Sid Sarkozy was my uncle, he died in a fire before I was born. He was a firefighter in –”
“Port’s Ferry?” he asks. I nod.
“Well, I’ll be damned.” He stares at me for a long moment, apparently torn about something. He tells me to wait where I am. He walks to his car, pulls out a water bottle, and hands it to me.
“Drink this. My backup will be here soon, don’t tell them where you got it from. It will help you pass the breathalyzer at the station, my field unit is conveniently broken right now.”
I look at him in bewilderment. “Sir, what –”
He looks at me hard. “Son, I’ve been warning Jimmy to keep off this highway and head to the shelter for six months. He has been an accident waiting to happen – he’ll jump out in front of cars to get them to stop and give him change. There’s nothing you could have done. But you get caught above the legal limit on a breathalyzer after hitting him and your life is done for.”
I keep my mouth shut and just stare at him, unable to respond. Finally, he sighs and takes off his hat. I hold back a gasp as I see burn scars snaking the left half of his head and the back of his neck. He sees me staring and says with certain gravity, “Let’s just say I owed your uncle a big favor and leave it at that.” He puts his hat back on and walks towards where the other cars will be parking.
I can hear the other sirens now. The second police car pulls up behind him, along with an ambulance. I down my water bottle and don’t say another word.
***
I walk out of the police station the next morning and crawl into the waiting cab.
“Where to?” the driver asks. I start to give him my home address, but change my mind. “The Café Romano on Eighth and Wallace downtown, you familiar with it?” I can’t explain, even to myself, why a coffee shop is the first place I want to go, especially after not sleeping all night. The cabbie rolls his eyes at my naiveté of his direction skills and pulls away from the sidewalk a little quicker than necessary. I can feel the soreness seize in my muscles and my heart beats a bit quicker as his tires nudge the curb. I take a deep breath. It could take awhile to get used to riding in cars again. Several minutes later, he drops me off in front of the brick building, and I hand him a bill and tell him to keep the change.
The place looks the same as it always has – forest green walls, a cocoa-colored floor, the heavenly aromas of cinnamon and Arabica beans intermingling and drawing me towards the counter where I purchase a latte with an extra shot of much-needed espresso.
The scene is almost too peaceful after a night like last night. Images and sounds keep flashing across my mind – Jimmy’s grateful smile in contrast to his twisted, bloody face, the look in Ella’s eyes as I left her room, the officer’s burn scars, the EMTs examining me, the police interrogating me, my hysterical mother on the phone, swearing she’ll never leave town again, saying she’s catching the next flight back from Detroit. Twelve hours feels so much more like twelve months.
I settle into my favorite corner where I can watch people walk outside. I sip slowly. Minutes tick by. I reach into my pocket to put away my wallet and out comes a small card. Looking for a second chance? it reads. Despite myself, I can’t help but crack a smile at all of the god damn irony. I leave the card on the table, then reach back into my pocket for my cell phone. I scroll through the contacts, settling on Ella’s name. I set the phone down. My pride threatens to shut it off or throw it out the window. I glance at the card next to me and pick the phone back up. I send her a quick text. Meet me at our place in ten?
Her response is nearly immediate. If you’re lucky.
I smile, set down the phone, sip my latte, and wait.